Why You Always Want to Fix Their Problems (And Why It Backfires)

Why do you always want to fix their problems, even when they just want to talk? This episode of Self Full explains why the urge to fix comes up so fast, why even good advice and kind words can land so badly, and when your advice actually helps. Three tools: Listen for How They Feel, Tell Them What You Heard, and Offer Before You Advise.


Enjoying the show? A quick rating or review on Apple Podcasts takes 20 seconds — and it’s the #1 way new listeners find Self Full. 💙

Prefer to read? This episode also exists as a full written guide: How to Stop Fixing Other People’s Problems (And What Helps).

Frequently asked questions

Why do I always try to fix other people’s problems?

Because you care, and because their pain gets into you too. Other people’s feelings spread, kind of the way a yawn does, so when someone you love is hurting, your chest gets tight and you get restless. Fixing the problem, or cheering them up, feels like the quickest way to make that stop. The rush to fix it is often your way out, not theirs.

Why does my advice make things worse when I’m only trying to help?

Usually not because the advice is bad, but because it shows up before they’re ready for it. In studies of couples under stress and of people preparing for a stressful speech, support that was obvious often didn’t help and sometimes added stress, while support that barely felt like help calmed people the most. Advice nobody asked for is about as obvious as help gets, and it can sound like you doubt they can handle it.

What should I say when someone is upset?

First, listen for how they feel and find it in a word or two: embarrassed, scared, worn out, hurt. Then tell them what you heard, in your own words – what happened and how it sounds like they’re feeling, like “you’ve been taking care of your mom all week, and nobody’s asking how you’re doing. That sounds lonely.” Then stop and let them keep going. If you get it wrong, they’ll usually correct you.

When is it okay to give advice?

When they ask for it, or when they’re ready. Once they’ve felt heard, they usually slow down or say something like “I don’t even know what to do.” Then offer before you advise: “I’ve got an idea about this. Do you want to hear it? Or do you just want to vent for now?” Mean both options. If they say yes, give one idea, not a whole list. And if someone is grieving, there may be nothing to solve at all.

Read the full transcript

Have you ever tried to help someone who was sad, stressed, or angry, and somehow made things worse? Maybe at lunch, your friend said her brother is moving across the country next month, and almost right away, you hear yourself say, “at least there’s video chat.” And then she just said, “yeah,” and looks down at her food. Or say your partner gets home from work and tells you her boss took credit for her idea in a meeting, in front of everyone.

And before she’s even finished, you’ve got it figured out. She should email him tonight and copy his manager, or go to HR, or maybe it’s time to start looking for a new job. And then she looks at you and said, “I’m not asking you to fix it.” Now, she’s quieter than when she walked in.

And you’re sitting there thinking, I was only trying to help. And honestly, your idea weren’t even bad. Most people would say the answer is simple, just listen more. But you were listening.

You heard every word she said. And that’s how you came up with these ideas so fast. But somehow, your partner is having none of it. So, if the people in your life comes to you when they’re hurting, and you go straight to fixing it or cheering them up, and your help doesn’t land the way you hoped, then this episode is for you.

Welcome to Self Full, the show where we look at why caring about someone doesn’t always come out the way we meant it. My name is Wilson, and I’ve been a fixer for the longest time. When someone comes to me with a problem, my brain starts working on it before they’ve even finished the sentence. And I used to think that was the most helpful thing I could do for anybody.

And if you do this too, it doesn’t make you a bad friend or a bad partner. Almost everybody does it. And they do it because they care about the person who’s hurting. So today, we’ll look at why the urge to fix comes up so fast.

Why even good advice and kind words can land so badly. And how to know when your advice will actually help. So stick around, because the people you care about are going to keep coming to you with hard things. And when they do, you’ll know how to help them walk away feeling better instead of worse.

So let’s slow down the moment someone comes to us hurting, because it all happens really fast. Say someone we care about starts talking about something that went wrong. Maybe it’s a fight with a friend, a rejection they didn’t see coming, or a week where everything is piling up. By their second sentence, we’ve spotted the problem.

And by the third, we’ve got an answer ready. And from there, part of us was just waiting for them to stop talking so we can say it. And the answer isn’t always advice. Sometimes we try to cheer them up instead.

And we say something like, “you’ll find something better.” Or, “everything happens for a reason.” Or, “I’m sure it’s not as bad as you think.” Those are fixes too.

They just aim at the feeling instead of the problem. Now, I’m not talking about when someone asks you straight out, “what should I do?” Then they want your advice. So go ahead and answer them.

And if someone said they’re thinking about hurting themselves, or that they’re not safe, that’s not something to handle by yourself. Stay with them and get help right away from a crisis line or emergency services. This episode isn’t about that. What I mean is the ordinary hard stuff.

Like the kind of thing people bring to the people they trust. So, why is the urge to fix it so hard to hold back, even when part of us know they just want to talk? Which leads us to the first point.

Point 1: What Happens Inside You While They Talk

Back in 2010, a team at Princeton led by Uri Hasson scanned the brain of a person telling a story. Then they played a recording of the story to other people, and scanned the listener’s brains too. And the listener’s brains started to sync up with the storytellers. The better someone followed the story, the more their brain activity matched.

And when people heard a story they couldn’t follow, the matching wasn’t there. That study was about following a story, not about feelings. But I think it shows something about listening. When you really follow someone, your brain starts working a little like theirs.

And something like that happens with feelings too. People who study emotions call it emotional contagion. It means other people’s feelings can spread to you. Kind of the way a yawn does.

So when someone you care about is talking about something painful, some of that pain gets into you too. It’s almost as if you can feel it in your body. Your chest gets tight, and you get restless. Like, you need to do something about it.

And I notice this most with my closest friends and family. When one of them calls me with bad news, my leg would start bouncing before I even heard the full story. And it seems like the quickest way to make that go away is to fix things for them. So you try to solve the problem, or cheer them up because if they stop hurting, so will you.

The rush to fix it is often your way out, not theirs. Your body isn’t being selfish here. It’s just trying to get out of the hurt as fast as it can. But while you’re putting an answer together, your attention moves often, so you can hear every word and still miss the person saying them.

So what do you do with that restlessness? And the first tool is this. Listen for how they feel. I don’t mean what happened or what they should do about it.

You’re already good at hearing the problem. I mean how they feel about it. And that usually comes down to one or two words like “embarrassed,” “scared,”

“worn out,” or “hurt.” And here’s how you use it. The moment you feel yourself getting restless, let that be your cue. Instead of putting together an answer, give your brain one job.

Listen for the feeling. And keep listening until you can say it in a word or two. This is all happening in your head, so nobody has to know you’re doing it. And once you’ve got that word, you’ll find the urge to fix it has eased up a little.

Let’s try it right now. Think of the last person who came to you with something hard. Skip what happened and think about how they feel. If you had to say it in one word, what would it be?

That word is what you’re listening for. Here’s what that might look like in a scenario. Say it’s the weeknight and you’re making dinner when your best friend Nadia calls. Her boyfriend broke up with her an hour ago.

And she’s crying so hard she can barely get the words out. And your brain is already on it. “Block his number.” “Delete the photos.”

“Honestly, you’ve never liked him that much,” and you’re about to say so. But your chest is tight and you noticed it. So you turn the stove down and you listen for how she feels. And then she keeps saying things like, “I told my mom he was the one.

I told everyone. Now I have to explain it all to them.” And then you noticed it. She isn’t just sad.

She’s embarrassed. And now that you’ve heard that, blocking his number doesn’t seem like the thing to say anymore. And you’re not in such a hurry to say anything at all. And this works because that restlessness wants the job.

If you just try to stop fixing, the urge keeps pushing. But lessening for a feeling is a job within the end. You’re looking for one or two words. And once you have them, that job is done.

And look at what that one word did on the phone with Nadia. Blocking the ex-boyfriend’s number would have been an answer to the breakup. But what she was really dreading was having to explain it to everyone. So you would have fixed the wrong thing.

And some days, you will be three ideas in before you remember. And that’s okay. Stop where you are and start listening for the feeling from there. So listening for the feeling keeps you in the conversation instead of off in your head, building a fix.

But you might still be wondering why a good idea or a kind word can land so badly in the first place, which leads to the next point.

Point 2: What Your Help Sounds Like From Their Side

A therapist once wrote about a day when she got some terrible news. A passenger plane had been shot down over a war zone and the people on board had nothing to do with the war. She felt awful and she really needed to be with someone. The first two people she talked to started trying to figure it out right away.

“Who did it?” “How did it happen?” “Why?” They weren’t giving her advice, but they were doing something close to it because they were busy with the facts instead of being with her.

And she felt worse. Her body tensed up and she felt more alone with the news than before. That evening, she talked to one more person. And this time, that person didn’t say anything at all.

She could just see in their face that they felt it too. And everything changed. Her body started to let go. And she started to cry.

And she didn’t feel alone with it anymore. She didn’t blame the first two people either because she thought their bodies had just protected them from feeling it. That’s the same thing we talked about in point one. And you’ve been on her side of this too.

We all have. Think back to a time you’d opened up about something that hurt, and the other person jumped straight to what you should do or to look on the bright side. You probably said, “yeah, maybe.” And then you changed the subject.

And you didn’t bring it up with them again. I’ve been on that side too. When one of my dogs passed away, it hit me harder than I let on. And almost everyone I talked to went straight to something like, “at least you gave your dog a great life,” or “maybe it’s time to get a new puppy.”

And after a while, I just kept it to myself. And that actually reminds me of a story. There’s a psychologist named Ethan Kross once asked a room full of people what they call someone who jumps right into advice before they’ve listened. Most of the people in the room said, “jerks.”

And one person in the back yelled, “husband.” And as a husband, I’m not going to argue with that one. You’ll hear why a little later, but I digress. There’s a reason advice can feel that bad, even when it’s good advice.

And if you had to guess, you’d probably say help works best when the person knows they’re getting it. But back in the year 2000, a group of researchers led by Niall Bolger had couples keep a daily diary while one partner went through something really stressful. And the help that went along with doing better was often help the stressed person hadn’t even noticed. So in year 2007, Bolger and another psychologist, David Amarel, tested the idea in a lab.

Women were told they’d had to give a speech, which stresses out almost anybody. While they got ready, another participant who was secretly working with the researchers gave them some support. For some of the women, the support was out in the open, aimed right at them. For others, it was slipped in so it didn’t really feel like help.

The hidden support calmed people down the most, and that was true for practical help and for comfort. The obvious support didn’t help, and sometimes it made them more stressed, because by receiving the obvious support, it insinuated that these women cannot handle it. Those studies weren’t about advice, but I think advice nobody asked for is about as obvious as help gets. And cheering someone up the second they start talking is pretty obvious too.

That’s why both of them can quietly send that same message. See, the help they didn’t ask for can sound like you doubted them. So if a fix isn’t the first thing they need, what is? Let me show you what it looks like before I give it a name.

Say it’s Saturday afternoon at your parents’ house, and your little sister Lily is sitting on the stairs, staring at her phone. She just found out a gallery turned down her paintings for the show she’d been working towards all year. And of course, your first thought is to cheer her up. She can try again next year.

There are other galleries. Her paintings are really good. But you’ve been listening for how she feels, and it sounds like she’s crushed. So instead of fixing it, you say back what you heard.

You say, “Lily, you worked on those paintings for a month, and they turned you down in one email. That must be crushing.” And she shakes her head and says, “It’s not even that. I’m scared I’m not actually good at this.”

And so you say that back too. “Okay, Lily, so it’s not really about this show. You’re scared you’re not as good as you’d hope.” And she puts her phone down, and she starts talking about the art teacher who once said her work was too safe. 10 minutes later, she’s still talking, and you still haven’t given her a single piece of advice.

And that’s the second tool. Tell them what you heard. Take the feeling you were listening for and put it into a sentence or two. Say what happened and how it sounds like they’re feeling.

Something like, “you’ve been taking care of your mom all week, and nobody’s asking how you’re doing. That sounds lonely.” And then stop right there and let them keep going. Use your own words, the way you normally talk, because if it sounds like a script, they’ll hear the script.

And you don’t have to get it right. If you’re wrong, they’ll usually correct you, the way Lily did. And the correction is worth a lot, because it shows you what’s really going on. And if someone ever says, “why are you repeating me?”

It means you gave them back their words instead of the feeling under them. So go for the feelings instead. When you tell them what you heard, you’re doing out loud what that silent face did for the therapist that we mentioned in the beginning of this point. It lets them know you’re with them, and that you’re not trying to hurry them out of the feeling.

And look at what that took Lily. You didn’t solve anything. But once she felt heard, she went straight to what was bothering her most, the part it fixed would have missed. And you’ll usually see a sign that it worked.

They keep talking, or they slow down, or they let out a long breath. So now they’ve had a chance to feel heard. But sooner or later, you’re going to want to share the idea you’ve had since their second sentence. So when does your advice get its turn?

Which leads us to the final point.

Point 3: The Other Half of Helping

Your advice is going to get its turn. But first, here’s one more reason listening matters so much. In 2012, two neuroscientists at Harvard, Diana Tamir and Jason Mitchell, scanned people’s brain while they talk about their own thoughts and opinions. And while they talked about someone else’s, they found that talking about themselves lit up their brain’s reward system.

Will you give up money for the chance to talk about yourself? A lot of the people in that study did. Those people weren’t going through anything hard. They were just sharing what they thought.

But the study showed how much people want to be heard. So when someone comes to you hurting, the talking is part of what they came for. But talking on its own has a limit. If all you ever do is agree and pile on, it can actually keep them stuck.

People who study this call it co-rumination. It’s when two people go over the same problem again and again and keep stirring it up. You say things like, “He’s such a jerk.” “You should be furious.”

“I’d never talk to him again.” You both end up more worked up than when you started. It feels close and it can be good for a friendship. But it doesn’t help them work through what actually happened.

So good support has two parts. First, they need to feel heard. And then, often, they need a little help seeing the problem differently, like a new idea or a way forward. And the order matters.

They need to get the feelings out before they can take in anything new. And the stronger the feeling, the longer that usually takes. Your advice usually isn’t the problem. It just shows up before they’re ready for it.

See, you probably got an advice you were glad about later. Maybe your friend was honest about someone you were dating. Or a parent said, Maybe this job isn’t for you. The first time you heard it, you didn’t want it.

But once you calmed down a little bit, or when you actually went through it the hard way, you realized that those advice actually helped. Eventually, a lot of people do want a way out of the feeling. That’s what your advice is for. So how do you know when they’re ready for it?

And here’s the third tool. Offer before you advise. Once you’ve told them what you heard, wait for them to slow down. You’ll usually see it when it happens.

They stop going over the same thing, or they say something like, “I don’t even know what to do.” That’s your moment. Don’t just hand them the answer. Offer it first.

And let them choose. Something like, “I’ve got an idea about this. Do you want to hear it? Or do you just want to vent for now?”

And mean both options. Because venting for now is a real answer. And it’s a good one. If they say yes, give them one idea.

Not a whole list. The one you think will help the most. If they say no, go back to listening. Your idea isn’t gone.

It’s just waiting. And they’ll often come back to it on their own. Whether it be later that day, or a few days later. And if they say, “just give me something, what do I do?”

Then go ahead. Because they ask. If you’ve been listening to the same problem for weeks, and it keeps getting worse, you can offer again, gently. That’s part of caring about them too.

And sometimes there’s nothing to solve at all. Like when someone’s grieving. Then you don’t need an idea. Listening for how they feel, and telling them what you’ve heard, is the whole job.

And knowing your idea would get this chance, help with the first two tools too. It’s hard to keep listening for how someone feels, when you think your idea is about to die in your head. But once you know it has a place to go, you can hold on to it and stay with them first. And when you’ve already told them what you heard, the advice you offer is more likely to be aimed at the right problem.

Here’s a scenario that includes all three tools. Say it’s Thursday night after your soccer game, and you’re getting a drink with Andre from your team. He’s been quiet all night. And finally he says his landlord is selling the building.

He’s lived there for six years, and he has to be out in five weeks. And you already know exactly where he should look. The neighborhood group chat where you found your apartment. But this time, you hold on to it, and you listen for how he feels.

He doesn’t sound angry so much as overwhelmed. So you tell them what you heard. You said, “Andre, you lived there for six years, and now you’ve got five weeks to find a new place and move out of there. That sounds overwhelming.”

And he says, “Yeah, I don’t even know where to start.” And so you offer it. You say, “I’ve got an idea about where to look if you want it. Or do you want to just complain about it for a while?”

And he laughs a little and says, “Honestly? Complain.” So he complains. And for about 10 minutes later, he looks over and says, “Okay, how did you find your apartment again?”

And this time, when you bring up the neighborhood group chat, he takes out his phone and asks you to send him the link. See, offering first put the timing in their hands. And that’s where the timing belongs. Because the person who’s hurting is the only one who knows when they’re ready to hear something new.

And look at what happened with Andre. It was the same idea you had in the first 10 seconds. It worked because he had asked for it. And it wouldn’t always go that smoothly.

Sometimes they’ll say no. And you’ll sit there with your good ideas feeling a little useless. That’s normal. And that’s okay.

You didn’t do it wrong. Sometimes some people are just not ready for it. And I learned this the hard way. A few years ago, my wife was really frustrated with her job.

She had way more work than one person should. There was a co-worker who kept making it harder. And she felt stuck. And whenever she brought it up, I’d jump right in.

I’d say things like, “Make a list of everything on your plate and show it to your boss.” “Stop answering that co-worker after 6.” I’ll even say something like, “Look, if you don’t like the job or this job is too stressful, just quit.” Sometimes she wouldn’t say anything.

And sometimes she’d get frustrated and ask me to please stop talking about it, even though she was the one that brought it up in the first place. And so you can imagine that really made me feel some type of way. But I remember one night when she came home and started complaining about her work again. I mean, my head at the time was also generating advices as usual.

But then I realized that, “You know what? This will never work.” So I told her what I heard. I said, “So it’s not just tonight.

It’s the workload and that co-worker who seems to be bothering you so much, and the feeling like nothing ever going to change. No wonder you feel stuck.” She paused for a second and said, “Yeah, I do feel stuck.” And then continued with the story for a little bit.

And then I asked her, “So do you want to hear what I’m thinking or do you just want to vent?” And she said, Just vent. And I’ll be honest, that was hard for me. I had my whole list ready in my head and nowhere to put it.

But I listened. And she talked longer that night than she had in a month. And nowadays, most of the time, she still handles her work stuff herself. She’s good at it.

But when it’s something she knows I can actually help with, she would ask me. Her job still gets to her sometimes, but she comes to me with it now a lot more than she used to. So the next time someone you care about comes to you hurting, here’s how it can go. You feel the urge to jump in, and instead of putting the answer together, you’ll listen for how they feel.

When you’ve got the feeling, you’ll tell them what you heard in your own words and let them keep talking. And when they start to slow down, you’ll offer before your advice and let them decide when they’re ready for it. And you’re still going to jump in sometimes. Everybody does, especially with the people they love most.

When you catch yourself halfway through a fix, you can just stop and say, “Sorry, I jumped ahead, but please keep going.” That usually works better than you think. And over time, you might notice something change. People start coming to you sooner.

They bring you things before they figure them out. Because they know you’re not going to rush them out of what they’re feeling. And if there’s someone in your life who’s always ready with a fix, send them this episode. I think you know exactly who I’m talking about.

And if you try offering before you advice this week, I’d love to hear what they said. You can find me on Instagram at Self Full Podcast (@selffullpodcast), or leave me in the comment on whatever platform you’re listening to this podcast on. Wanting to fix things for people you love is a good thing to have in you. And you don’t have to lose that.

Your advice usually isn’t a problem. It just shows up before they’re ready for it. So let them be heard first. They need to know they’re not going through it by themselves.

And remember, I’m always here for you. Take care.


1 thought on “Why You Always Want to Fix Their Problems (And Why It Backfires)”

  1. Pingback: How to Stop Fixing Other People's Problems (And What Helps)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top