Why do you keep trying to impress people, even people who already like you? This episode of Self Full explains why it isn’t a big ego but a fear of not being enough, why your mind treats every conversation like an audition, and why impressing people backfires even when it works. Three tools: Who Is This For?, Pass on One Chance to Impress, and Admit to One Thing You’d Usually Hide.
Enjoying the show? A quick rating or review on Apple Podcasts takes 20 seconds — and it’s the #1 way new listeners find Self Full. 💙
Prefer to read? This episode also exists as a full written guide: How to Stop Trying to Impress People (And Why You Do It).
Frequently asked questions
Why do I always try to impress people?
Usually not because you think you’re better than everyone. It’s the opposite: somewhere underneath, you’re scared you’re not enough, so you keep working to make sure nobody finds out. For most of human history, what people thought of you decided whether they helped you and whether they wanted you around, so your mind learned to treat being looked down on like a real danger.
Why do I try to impress people who already like me?
Because your mind treats every conversation like a first impression – an audition. But the people who already know you formed their opinion slowly, over years, and one conversation almost never changes it. Research has found that people are more modest with someone who has already heard good things about them; if you’ve been impressing people for a long time, your mind just doesn’t always notice that the audition ended.
Can trying to impress people backfire?
Yes, in two ways. The part of your mind that’s watching how you come across isn’t listening, so you miss things and come across stiffer. And saying you’re better than other people, rather than just good at something, tends to make people like you less and see you as colder, because they hear a put-down. You can end up making them feel small – the exact thing you were scared of.
How do I stop trying to impress people?
Start by noticing it. When you feel yourself about to say something to look good, ask: who is this for, and what am I scared they’ll think if I don’t say it? Then, once this week, let one chance to impress go by and put your attention back on the other person. And admit one small, true thing you’d usually hide, like “I was nervous coming here tonight.” Often the other person relaxes and says, “honestly, me too.”
Read the full transcript
Have you ever noticed that you’re always trying to impress people? Even people you don’t need to impress at all? And here’s the honest truth, I know I have, for a long, long time. And it goes something like this.
You’re telling a story, and you make it a little bigger than it really was. Someone asks how your week went, and somehow you work in the one impressive thing that happened. Everyone laughs at a joke, and you laugh too, even though you didn’t get it. And afterwards, you get this small, tired feeling, and you think, “why did I even do that in the first place?”
Most people will call that showing off, or having a big ego. But a lot of the time, it’s the opposite. It’s not like you think you’re better than everyone. It’s that somewhere underneath, you’re scared you’re not enough.
And so you keep working to make sure nobody finds out. So if you can’t seem to stop trying to impress people, and it’s wearing you out. If trying to impress people has become such a habit that it feels like a part of your personality, and you’re not even sure who’d you be without it, then this episode is for you. Welcome to Self Full, the show where we figure out why we work so hard to be seen in a certain way.
My name is Wilson, and I know that fear of not being enough pretty well. For me, it was mostly a fear of being looked down on. I was scared people would think I wasn’t smart enough, or strong enough, or witty enough, or even a decent enough person. So I spent a lot of energy making sure that nobody ever got the chance to look down on me.
So much so that it pretty much became a habit. And I won’t tell you to just be yourself, or stop caring what people think. If either of those worked, you’d have done it by now. So needing to impress people doesn’t make you fake or shallow.
Almost everybody does some of this, just that some of us never get to turn it off. And so today, there are three things I want to get into. First, why your mind works so hard to impress people at all. Second, why impressing people backfires, even when it seems to be working.
And third, what actually brings people closer. And this is a topic that I wish somebody had explained to me years ago. So stick around, because what I want for you is simple. To be able to sit with people and just be there, without the performance.
So let me be clear about what I mean by impressing people. I don’t mean wanting to do well at your job. I don’t mean telling your best friend about something good that happened to you. What I mean is the little things you add to make yourself look better.
The bigger numbers, the smarter words, the story that beats the one they just told. You don’t add them because they’re true or because anyone asked. You add them because you’re scared of what people would think of you without them. And when you’re doing that all the time, life starts to feel like one long audition.
Every conversation, you’re trying out for a part. And after a while, you find yourself being exhausted because it never seems to end. But at the same time, you just can’t stop trying to impress people. So the question is, why can’t you stop, even with people who already like you, which leads us to the first point.
Point 1: What Your Mind Thinks Is at Stake
Back in 2010, two psychologists, Richard Ronay and Bill von Hippel, ran an experiment at a skate park in Brisbane, Australia. They watched young men between 18 and 25 trying tricks. A man from the research team watched some of the skaters, while an attractive young woman watched the others. When the woman was watching, the guys at a skate park went for the harder trick, and their testosterone went up.
And when a trick started to go wrong, they were less likely to bail out. So they landed more tricks, but they also crashed more. I mean, think about it. They’d rather fall hard than have her think that they were scared.
That’s how strong the pull to impress people can be. And it’s not just because those guys were shallow, or that they’re just men. And this actually applies to both men and women. It’s because for most human history, what people thought of you decided a lot.
It decided whether they helped you when you needed it, and whether they want you around at all. A good reputation kept you safe, while a bad reputation made life a lot harder. So your mind learned to treat being looked down on like a real danger. And you learned that looking bad counts more than looking good.
One moment of looking small can feel bigger than 10 moments of looking great. But your mind makes a mistake here. It treats every conversation like the first impression. Like, this is the moment people will decide who you are.
But most conversations aren’t like that. You spend most of your life with people who already know you. Your friends, your family, the people you work with. They’ve seen you on good days and bad days.
They form their opinions of you slowly over years, and one conversation almost never changes it. And when people already think well of you, the need to impress them usually eases up. Back in 1978, two psychologists, Roy Baumeister and Edward Jones, found exactly that. When people met someone who’d already heard great things about them, they were more modest about themselves.
But if you’ve been trying to impress people for a long time, your mind doesn’t always notice when they already think well of you. It keeps trying anyway. Your mind treats every conversation like an audition. But with the people who already know you, the audition ended a long time ago.
So, how do you notice the urge to impress while it’s happening instead of an hour later? The first tool is a question you ask yourself, right when you feel yourself about to ask something just to look good. And the question goes, “Who is this for?” I don’t mean who you’re talking to.
I mean who you’re trying to impress. Sometimes it’s the person in front of you. And sometimes it’s someone who isn’t even there, like a parent, an old boss, or the kid who made fun of you back in elementary school. Then ask yourself one more thing.
“What am I scared they’ll think if I don’t say it?” Usually the answer is short. That I’m not smart. That I’m boring.
That I’m not doing as well as they are. You don’t have to stop yourself yet. Just ask those questions. You’re finding out two things.
Who you’re performing for. And what you’re scared they’ll see. And once you know those two things, the urge loses a lot of its pull. Let me give you another scenario.
Let’s say it’s a Sunday afternoon at a friend’s place. And you’re playing a board game with a few people you just met. Including a guy named Marcus. And somewhere between rounds, Marcus mentions that he runs five days a week before work.
And before you can stop yourself, you’re saying, “Oh, I ran a half marathon.” You don’t mention that it was three years ago. And you’re about to tell him you’re finished time too. But before you do, you catch yourself.
So you start asking yourself, “Who is this for?” And you found out that, well, it’s for Marcus mostly. But he’s a guy that you just met 40 minutes ago. And you ask yourself the second question.
What are you scared he’ll think if you don’t say it? And you realize that, if you don’t say it, that next to him, you might seem that you’re lazy. Or not strong enough. Or not the kind of person who has it all together.
And just like that, telling him your time doesn’t feel so urgent anymore. And you now know what it was really about. This helps because the urge to impress moves fast. By the time you notice it, you’re usually already said it.
Asking who’s it for slows you down for a second, long enough to notice what you’re doing. And look at what you found out. It wasn’t really about Marcus. It was about a fear you brought in with you.
And you probably had it for years. It doesn’t really care who’s in front of you. And even if you still have the urge to say or do things to impress people, that is okay. This first tool is about self-awareness, not about stopping yourself.
Self-awareness here is key, since most people don’t even notice that they’re doing it. And I did this a lot myself. I remember when I first started working at my family’s textile business in Taiwan, more than anything, I was scared that everyone would think that I only had this job because of my dad. So, during any meetings, whether it be with clients, suppliers, or even co-workers, if there were technical words or phrases that I didn’t know about, I would pretend that I do.
Even though I’d only be in the company for a couple of months. But I remember one afternoon when I was meeting with an overseas client, and he asked me a follow-up question about one of those words, and I had no idea what the answer was. I was caught on the spot for a couple of seconds until one of my co-workers rescued me by answering the question, which made it even worse. Not only I made a fool of myself in front of the client, but also in front of my co-worker.
I replayed that scene over and over again in my head for maybe a few weeks. Eventually, I started asking myself, when I pretend to know all of those technical words about textile, who was it for? And I realized that the answer was almost always the same. It was for whoever I thought might be wondering if I’d earned my spot.
And once I could see that, I had to be honest with myself. Some people really did say that I only got the job because of my family. Not everyone, but some. And that was the thing I was most afraid of.
So I was trying to prove it wrong in every meeting, even with people who never thought of it at all. See, I noticed that I already know this answer. I’ve known this answer since the first day I started working there. But I just didn’t want to admit it.
I didn’t want to admit that I knew nothing about textile. So I started pretending. So that’s the first tool. That question gets you to the fear underneath.
But you might be thinking, so what? Maybe a little impressing is harmless, which leads to the next point.
Point 2: Why Trying to Impress People So Hard Can Backfire
First, picture a second date that’s actually going pretty well. Say it’s Saturday night at a small Thai place, and you’re across the table from Sam. Sam is funny and easy to talk to, and you really want this to go somewhere. So while Sam is talking about his sister’s wedding, you’re half listening and half planning.
You’ve got a great story about the time you met a famous chef, and you’re waiting for the right moment to bring it up. And then Sam stops and say, “sorry, am I boring you?” And you realize that you have no idea what Sam just said. And here’s what’s happened there.
You were so busy trying to impress Sam that you stopped actually listening to Sam. Trying to impress people can backfire in two ways. The first is about where your attention goes. Back in 1993, a sports scientist named Rich Masters and his colleague came up with a short questionnaire that measures how self-conscious people are.
It has statements like, I’m self-conscious about the way I look, and research using it keep finding the same thing. The higher people score, the more likely they are to choke under pressure. In sports, in music, and in other big moments. Those studies weren’t about conversations, but a conversation can work the same way.
If part of your mind is busy watching how you’re coming across, that part isn’t listening. You miss things, you get a little stiff, or your jokes come out a beat later. The other is what it does to the person you’re talking to. In 2016, a team of psychologists in Belgium, led by Caroline Van Damme, asked people to judge two kinds of bragging.
One person said they were good at something. The other said they were better than other people. People didn’t think the second person was any less capable. They just liked them less, and saw them as colder.
Because underneath, they heard a put-down. They heard, “I’m better than you.” So, even when bragging works, and people believed you, it can still come across as an insult, whether you meant it that way or not. And when people can tell you’re trying hard to be liked, they tend to like you less, not more.
When you’re trying to impress people, you can end up making them feel small, which is the exact thing you were scared of. So, if the urge isn’t going anywhere, how do you handle it? And here’s the second tool. Pass on one chance to impress.
Pick one conversation this week. When you catch yourself about to say something just to impress someone, don’t say it. Let that one go by, and put your attention back on them. What did they just say?
What do you actually want to know about? And that’s it. One time. You don’t need to do this in every conversation.
It’s probably going to feel like you’re giving something up, like a chance to look good is going by, and you’re just watching it go. You’ll feel a little itch to say it anyway, and that’s normal, and it usually fades within a minute or two. Let’s look back on that scenario we mentioned earlier, but a few minutes later. Sam picks the wedding story back up, and this time, you’re actually listening.
And sure enough, the urge to tell your chef story comes back, right on cue. But you catch yourself this time, and you let it go by. And because you were listening, you heard that Sam’s sister walked down the aisle to a song from a video game. And both of you giggles, for real this time.
And then you ask which game. And 20 minutes later, the two of you are still talking about it. And you haven’t once thought about how you are coming across. But then you realize that both you and Sam are genuinely having a great time together.
See, letting that one chance go by gives you your attention back. The part of your mind that was busy watching you is free to do what is actually good at, which is paying attention to somebody else. And it stops the bragging that was quietly pushing Sam away. Nobody walks out of a date thinking, “I wish they bragged more.”
They walked out remembering how it felt to be listened to. And notice what it didn’t happen. Sam didn’t think less of you for skipping the chef story. Sam never knew it existed.
So now you’re actually listening. But you’re still wondering what the other person thinks of you, which leads to the final point.
Point 3: Who You’re Really Talking To
Think about the last time you met someone who seems completely confident, like they had nothing to prove. There’s a good chance that the person went home that night and replaced something they said the same way you might. See, we all show the world a certain version of ourself. And most of us pretend that we’re not doing it.
It shows up in small ways. We smile when we don’t feel like smiling. We round our numbers up. We mentioned the good part of the year and leave out the rest.
So underneath, the person across from you is often worried about the same thing you are. They’re wondering whether you think they’re enough. The people you’re trying to impress are usually trying just as hard to impress you. And that means both of you are working hard and neither of you gets to relax.
So how does anybody ever actually get close? And here’s the third tool. And it’s the opposite of impressing anyone. Admit to one thing you’d usually hide.
Not a big secret reveal, but something small and true that you’d normally cover up so you look better. Something like, “I don’t actually know much about that.” Or, “I was nervous coming here tonight.” Or, “I’ve only made this once before and it didn’t turn out too great.”
Say it once this week to one person out loud in a real conversation. You might feel exposed for a second. That’s the feeling your mind has been trying to protect you from for years. But most of the time, something else happens.
The other person relaxes, and a lot of the time, they will say, “honestly, me too.” And what if they don’t? What if someone actually does look down on you for it? I mean, that could sting.
I won’t tell you that it doesn’t. But think about what it tells you. If someone needs you to look smaller so they can feel bigger, then they’re still busy trying to impress somebody themselves. And the people who already know you aren’t going to change their minds over one honest sentence.
Let me give you an example to explain this further. Say it’s Tuesday afternoon in a study room at a library, three days before you have to take a big exam. And there are four of you at the table, including Jack, who always seems to have everything under control. Everyone is going around sharing their scores on the practice test.
When it’s your turn, you’re about to round your score up or say you ran out of time. But this time, instead, you say, “honestly, I bombed it. I’m kind of panicking.” And for a second, nobody says anything.
Then Jack puts his pencil down and said, “Oh, thank God, me too.” And for the next two hours, the four of you actually studied together. And for once, nobody’s pretending they already understand it. Look at what happens at a table.
Nobody wanted to be the first to admit that they were struggling. And the moment one person did, the next one could too. And that’s usually where closeness starts. Not when somebody is impressed by you, but when someone sees something real about you.
See, one honest sentence did more at the table than an impressive score ever could. And admitting one small thing makes the first two tools easier. Once you’ve done it and watched the conversation get better instead of worse, your mind starts to believe it doesn’t have to work this hard. That first question gets easier to ask because you know what you’re looking for.
And letting a chance to impress go by stop feeling like you’re losing something. The need to impress people won’t disappear just because you understand where it’s coming from. But you can get better at noticing it and better at choosing what to do instead. That’s what the three tools are for.
The first tool is a question. When you feel yourself about to ask something to look good, ask yourself, who is this for? The answer usually isn’t the person you’re talking to. It’s an old fear that doesn’t fit your life anymore.
The second tool is to pass on one chance to impress. Let the bigger story stay unsaid and put your attention back on the conversation. You’ll hear more of what people are saying and they’ll notice that you’re really listening. And the third tool is to admit one thing you’d usually hide.
Something small and true like “I don’t know” or “I was nervous.” That’s often what lets both of you stop performing and actually talk. You don’t have to do all three at once. For most people, it changes slowly.
One conversation feels a little lighter than usual than the other one does. And one day, you’ll notice you walked out of a room without replaying a single thing you said. And perhaps that’s the day that you realize that you no longer have to put on the mask without you even noticing it. And if you know someone who always seems to be working hard to keep everyone impressed, they’re probably more scared than they look.
Send this episode to them. I think you know exactly who I’m talking about. And if this week, you admit to one thing that you usually hide, I’d love to hear what it was. You can find me on Instagram at Self Full Podcast (@selffullpodcast) or leave me in the comments on whatever platform you’re listening to this podcast on.
That urge to impress people isn’t proof that something is wrong with you. It’s just a habit that you picked up a long time ago, probably for a good reason. But the people who are going to stay in your life aren’t staying because you impressed them. They’re staying because they like being around you and that part you never had to perform.
And remember, I’m always here for you. Take care.