Making new friends gets harder as you get older, and the hard part usually isn’t meeting people. You still meet people you like, at work, at a party, through a partner or a hobby, and you both mean it when you say you should hang out. Then the weeks fill up, nobody follows through, and it starts to feel like everyone else knows how to do this and you’ve somehow forgotten.
Enjoying the show? A quick rating or review on Apple Podcasts takes 20 seconds — and it’s the #1 way new listeners find Self Full. 💙
Prefer to read? This episode also exists as a full written guide: How to Make Friends as an Adult (And Actually Keep Them).
Frequently asked questions
Why is it so hard to make friends as an adult?
Usually not because you got worse at it. School and early jobs kept putting you next to the same people over and over, whether anyone planned it or not, and friendships grew out of that. One study from the late 1940s looked at a new housing complex for married students, where most families didn’t know each other when they moved in. After everyone had lived there a while, the researchers asked residents who they spent the most time with. Who became friends depended mostly on how close their front doors were: people were far more likely to be close friends with the person right next door than with someone a few doors down. Adult life stops arranging that kind of contact for you, so friendships stop happening on their own.
Why does reaching out to someone new feel so risky?
Because it shows someone that you want to spend time with them, and if they say no or never write back, it can feel like they’ve decided you’re not worth their time. So you wait, and you tell yourself they probably aren’t as interested as you are. But people tend to like the people who clearly like them, so making it clear you enjoy someone’s company usually works in your favor. And the person you didn’t text might be sitting on an unsent message of their own.
Why do new friendships fizzle out after one good hangout?
Because adult friendships tend to happen in big, rare chunks: a birthday dinner here, a wedding there, and a catch-up that takes three weeks of texting to plan. Each one is planned from scratch, so each one feels a little like starting over. What turns someone you like into a real friend is mostly two things: a lot of ordinary time together, and knowing you’re going to see each other again. School gave you both of those for free. Adult life usually doesn’t.
What is a standing plan, and why does it help?
A standing plan is a plan that repeats, so you only have to ask once: same day, same thing. Tacos every other Tuesday, a walk every Sunday morning, or a phone call every Thursday on your drive home. Keep it small enough to survive your tired weeks; an hour is plenty. It works because it brings back the two things school used to give you, regular time together and a next time that’s already set, so one cancellation doesn’t end it.
Read the full transcript
Making new friends as an adult is a lot harder than it used to be. And the hard part usually isn’t meeting people. The hard part is everything that’s supposed to happen after you both say, “we should hang out sometime.” You probably still meet people you like.
At a friend’s birthday dinner, you end up talking to the same person all night. On the way out the door, you follow each other on Instagram and promise to get together soon, and you really do mean it. And then the week fills up, and neither of you text. Six months later, all the two of you have done is like each other’s post.
And that happens whether you just move to a new city, or you’ve lived in the same place for years and watched your old friends drift into their own lives. When that keeps happening, person after person, it stops feeling like bad luck. So it’s easy to decide the problem is you. That everybody else know how to make friends, and you just don’t anymore.
But you haven’t gotten worse at this. Something changed around you, and it happened so quietly that most people never noticed. So if you found that making new friends as you grow older is so much harder than you realized, even when you meet people you like, they just never turn into friends, then this episode is for you. Welcome to Self Full, the show where we try to understand why getting close to people gets harder as we get older.
My name is Wilson, and I’m not going to tell you to just put yourself out there. You’ve probably heard that a hundred times, and it doesn’t help, because you’ve probably been there and done that already. And if new friendship never seems to get off the ground for you, you’re definitely not the only one. So in this episode, we’ll look at why friendship stops happening on their own, why reaching out feels so much riskier than it really is, and what actually keeps a new friendship going.
For me, friends never came easy. The one I still have from high school started with a game of basketball at a park, and I’ll tell you about that later on. And once you see why making friends got so hard, you can start doing something about it. So stick around, because the friendship you want are more within reach than they feel right now.
Most of us have people in our lives, maybe a partner, maybe family, and a couple of old friends we catch up on with a few times a year. So this episode isn’t about having no friends, but one day you realize the last new friend you made was years ago, and now you only have a vague idea of how it came to be. And it can feel a little embarrassing, like something you should have figured out by now. This episode also isn’t about social anxiety so strong that it keeps you home.
That deserves real help and an episode of its own. And it isn’t about a friendship that ended badly either. What we’re talking about is the ordinary gap between meeting people you like and actually becoming friends with them. So how come making friends used to be so easy?
Why did friends just seem to show up when we were younger, and now it takes so much work? Which leads us to the first point.
Point 1: What School Was Doing for You
Think about how you met your closest friends. Not the moment you decided that you liked them, but the way you kept ending up near them. For most of us, it went something like this. You sat next to someone in class, or you were on the same team, or you had the same lunch break at your first job, and you saw them every single day, whether either of you planned it or not.
And somewhere in all that time, without anybody asking anybody, you became friends. School and those early jobs were doing something for us that we never noticed. They kept putting us next to the same people over and over. In the late 1940s, a psychologist at MIT named Leon Festinger and his team wanted to find how friends should form in a brand new community.
They studied a housing complex for married students, when most families didn’t know each other when they moved in. After everyone had lived there for a while, the researchers asked the resident who they spent the most time with. You would expect people to end up friends with whoever they had the most in common with. But who became friends depended mostly on how close their front doors were.
People were far more likely to be close friends with the person right next door than with someone just a few doors down. And the people who lived by the stairs or the mailboxes, where everybody walked past, made more friends than their neighbors did. See, that study was about neighbors, not classmates or co-workers. But your school hallway worked the same way.
Because you saw the same faces there every day. And so did your first job. Then school ends, and maybe you changed jobs, or you moved, or you started working from home. And little by little, you stopped running into the same people.
When I moved to a new town in high school, the guys who became my friends were the ones who had the same classes as me. If our class schedule had been different, I probably never would have gotten to know them. You didn’t choose most of your friends. You just kept running into them.
So, if your life doesn’t hand you those people anymore, where do you even begin? And that’s what the first tool is for. It’s called Map Your Regulars. Your regulars are the people you already see over and over without planning it.
The guy who’s always at the gym at 7. The parent you see at daycare pick up every afternoon. The neighbor you always see at the elevator. To map them, you ask yourself two things.
Where do you go at least once a week? And who’s usually there when you are? You’ll probably end up with two or three people. You might not know them well, or even know their names yet.
But they’re the closest thing adult life has to the kid who sat next to you in class. Which make them some of the likeliest people to become your friends. This isn’t about forcing a friendship with everyone you see. See, some of your regulars you won’t click with.
And that’s fine. You’re just finding out who’s in your week. Let’s do this one right now because it only takes a minute. Picture your week and the places you go.
Now picture who’s usually there. Even if you only know their first name or you don’t know them at all, they still count as regulars. Take a new job for example. Say you started at a new company six months ago.
And you mostly work with your own team, a few desks down from the kitchen. Every morning around nine, there’s the same guy from finance at a coffee machine. Let’s say his name is Daniel. And the two of you have said good morning more times than you can count.
One morning, you’re waiting for the coffee to finish. And you think about who your regulars are. And Daniel is the first person who comes to mind. And you realize you’ve been looking for new friends at parties and on apps.
And one of your best chance has been standing next to you every morning since your first week. See, mapping your regulars works because it points you at the people your life is already putting in front of you. You don’t have to create all that running into each other yourself. You just have to notice where it’s still happening.
And seeing someone again and again tends to make you like them more. As long as you didn’t dislike them to begin with. So your regulars have a head start. Your brain has been getting used to them every time you’ve crossed paths.
So your regulars are a good place to start. But knowing who you like to be friends with doesn’t make you reach out to them. And that’s usually where we get stuck. Which leads us to the next point.
Point 2: Why Reaching Out Feels So Risky
Here’s something a lot of us have done. You think of someone you’d like to see more of. And you type out a text: “Hey, want to get coffee sometime?” Then you look at it and think, that sounds weird.
Or they’re probably busy. Or they’ve already got enough friends. So you delete it. And you tell yourself you’ll text them later.
And I’ve done this more time than I like to admit. Once I spent 10 minutes staring at a text that just said, want to grab lunch sometime? I couldn’t decide whether that sentence would make me look too eager. See, reaching out feels risky because it shows someone that you want to spend time with them.
And if they say no or they never write back, it can feel like they’ve decided you’re not worth their time. So we wait. We tell ourselves the other person probably isn’t as interested as we are. One social psychologist who studied loneliness for 20 years said he’d have never met a single person who didn’t want friends.
So chances are, the person you didn’t text would like more friends too. And they might be sitting on an unsent message of their own. The truth is, people tend to like the people who clearly likes them. And that’s good news.
Because when someone makes it clear they enjoy your company, it’s really hard not to like them back. So when you say, we should hang out sometime, the other person can’t really tell whether you mean it. Everybody says it, because it’s how people end a conversation. So the word “sometime” doesn’t carry much weight.
And it doesn’t give either of you a next step. So how do you show someone you actually mean it, and keep the invitation small? And here’s the second tool. Pick the day.
The next time you hear yourself about to say “sometimes,” suggest a real day instead and something to do. Something like, “want to get ramen on Wednesday?” Not, “we should get food sometimes.” Avoid the word “sometimes.”
It’s a small change, but it does two things. Saying Wednesday shows them you actually want to see them. And as we just heard, that makes them much more likely to want to see you too. And Wednesday gives them something real to say yes to.
And sure, they might say no. Maybe Wednesday is a bad day for them. If they offer another day, great. If they don’t, you can try once more with a different day.
And if that doesn’t work either, just let it rest for a while. A no to Wednesday isn’t a no to you. People are busy and some friendships take two or three tries to get started. Let’s look at a scenario.
Say you go with your partners to a barbecue at one of their co-workers’ house. And you end up talking for an hour with a co-worker’s husband, Theo, about running. It turns out you both run the same trail by the river on weekends. And as you’re leaving, you hear yourself start to say, “We should go for a run sometimes.”
And before you say it out loud, you stop. And you pick the day instead. You say, “Are you running Saturday morning? I’ll do the river trail at 8 if you want to come.”
Theo looks a little bit surprised. And then he says, “Yeah, actually, 8 o’clock works.” And on the drive home, your partner glances over and says, “Look at you, making friends.” So picking the day gets you one real hangout.
But for a lot of adult friendship, one great hangout is where it ends. You both say, “Let’s do this again.” And then three months go by, which leads us to the final point.
Point 3: What Actually Keeps a Friendship Going
Most of what you’ve done with your oldest friend probably wasn’t special at all. It probably wasn’t the big night out. But it was all the small stuff in between. There are two things seems to turn someone you like into a real friend.
And the first is simply time together. A lot of it. And it doesn’t have to be exciting. Watching TV together counts.
Having breakfast together also counts. And even the hard time counts. It could be a stressful project, a road trip that went wrong, a team that keeps losing. In fact, people who go through something that’s rough side by side often comes out of it closer.
And the second thing is knowing you’re going to see each other again. When there’s always a next time, you can carry on right where you left off. See, our school years gave us both of those for free. You saw the same people every day and you always knew you’d see them tomorrow.
But adult friendships usually get the opposite. We see people in big, rare chunks. A birthday dinner here, a wedding there, and a catch-up every few months that takes three weeks of texting to plan. And every one of those has to be planned from scratch.
So each one actually kind of feels like starting over. See, friendships aren’t built in big night. They’re built in ordinary ones. I mean, think about it.
Have you ever had a friend you saw every week and never had to plan it? Did it feel easy? And do you remember how fast the two of you got close? So how do you get that kind of friendship back when nothing in your life sets it up for you anymore?
And here’s the third tool. Set a standing plan. A standing plan is a plan that repeats, so you only have to ask once. Same day, same thing.
It could be taco every other Tuesday, a walk every Sunday morning, or it could be a class you both signed up for. Start with one person, and keep it small, because it has to work on your tired weeks too. An hour is plenty. And when you suggest one, make it clear the plan repeats.
Not, “let’s do this again sometimes.” Something like, “This was fun. Want to make it a Tuesday thing?” A standing plan worked with the old friend you’ve drifted from too.
That could be a phone call every Thursday on your drive home from work. Some weeks, one of you will cancel. And that’s totally fine. The whole point of a standing plan is that it’s still there the next time.
So one cancellation doesn’t end it. And if the other person doesn’t want to make it a regular thing, that’s okay too. Some people really are stretched thin. You can still see them now and then, and you can set up a standing plan with someone else.
This works because it brings back both of the things schools used to give us. You keep seeing each other, and you always know when the next time is. And nobody has to feel like they’re starting from scratch every single time. And a standing plan makes your next invite easy.
Remember Theo from that barbecue? Let’s say your Saturday runs have turned into a regular thing. The next time you start talking with one of your regulars, like the guy at the gym, you don’t even have to pick a date. You can just say, “a couple of us run the river trail on Saturday at 8.
Want to come?” And let me give you another scenario. Say last summer, you went on a weekend hiking trip with a group of strangers, and you hit it off with a woman named Priya. It turned out she lives 15 minutes from you.
Since then, the two of you have gotten together twice. And both times were great. And both times, you said goodbye with, “we have to do this more.” So the third time, before you say goodbye, you pick the day, and you make it a standing plan.
You said, “every other Sunday, brunch at that place halfway between us. I’ll book it.” And she laughed and says, “okay, deal.” And a couple of brunches in, one day she has to cancel.
And you don’t worry about it, because there’s another one in two weeks. And earlier in this episode, I told you about the guys who had the same classes as me in high school. The standing plan that made us friends weren’t even my idea to begin with. For a while, we’d chat in class, but we weren’t close.
Class was the only place we ever saw each other. Then one day, one of them said, “let’s all go play basketball at the park after school.” And so we did. And then we did it again.
Pretty soon, it was a standing plan, and all of us kept showing up for it. And over time, we added more standing plan. Once a week, we’d go over to one guy’s house, because he had a jacuzzi in his backyard. We would hang out in the jacuzzi at night and play video games afterwards.
And after high school, I was the first of us to live on my own. I got an apartment in the same town, right across from the community pool, while everybody else was still living with their families. So I issued a standing plan of my own, barbecued by the poolside every week. Looking back on it, none of it was anything special.
Basketball, jacuzzi, barbecue. But we kept doing it, week after week. And a good number of those guys are still my friends today. I think most of us made our school friends that way, even if nobody ever called it a plan.
And I’m a long way from high school now. And these days, when I meet people that I like to be friends with, I’m the one who suggests a standing plan. And sometimes it lands, and sometimes it doesn’t. But the ones that lands are how I still make friends as an adult.
See, school years did a lot of the work of making friends for us, and adult life mostly doesn’t. So friendship don’t really happen by accident anymore, but you can still make them happen on purpose. Start by mapping your regulars, so you know who your life is already putting in front of you. When you meet someone you’d like to see again, pick the day, instead of saying “sometimes.”
And once you’ve had one or two good times together, set a standing plan so the next time is already on the calendar. The first few tries might be awkward. You might get a no, or a quiet first hangout. That doesn’t mean it isn’t working.
Because most new friendship feels a little stiff for the first few times. And then one day, they just don’t. And at the beginning of this episode, we talked about a scenario where you talked to someone all night at a birthday dinner, and six months later, all the two of you had done was like each other’s post on Instagram. See, there’s a good chance that person has been hoping you’d text first, the same way you’ve been hoping they would.
So maybe this is the week you text them. And remember, drop the word “sometimes.” Say an actual date. And if you know someone who just moved, or who’s been finding it hard to make new friends, send them this episode.
And if you started a standing plan with someone this week, tell me what the two of you picked. I genuinely want to hear about them. You can find me on Instagram at Self Full Podcast (@selffullpodcast), or leave me in the comment on whatever platform you’re listening to this podcast on. Unlike our school years, nobody is going to seat you next to the same people every day anymore.
But now you get to choose who you keep running into. Friendship aren’t built in big nights. They’re built in ordinary ones. So the next time you meet someone you’d like to be friends with, why not make a standing plan for the ordinary nights for both of you?
And remember, I’m always here for you. Take care.
Pingback: How to Make Friends as an Adult (And Actually Keep Them)